Great Question! I recommend watching these videos, they will help you understand how to approach these types of questions. The first video has multiple practice problems, the last question is on answering questions with IR, H NMR and C NMR and Mass Spectrometry.
Study With Us: Identifying Unknown Compounds Using IR and NMR Spectroscopy and Mass Spectrometry
Practice Problem: Determining the Identity of a Compound (C8H14) Using IR and HNMR
Practice Problem: Finding the Structure of a Molecule Using IR, NMR, and MS
Replied on Lesson: Mass Spectrometry
02 Jun 09:53
Were you referring to the example at timestamp 15:17 ? For this we were showing all the possible fragments which included the CH₃⁺ , notice that the fourth fragment shows that variation of the longer carbon chain as the radical and the methyl being the carbocation now. This is really just to show all the possible fragments and values that you'll see in the mass spectrum data.
If a CH₃ group breaks off, and the CH₃ keeps the charge, that means the other fragment became the neutral radical. That may seem strange since CH₃⁺ is not a very stable carbocation.Fragmentation doesn’t always favor the most hyperconjugated carbocation.
Sometimes, a methyl shift or cleavage happens simply because it’s energetically favorable or statistically more likely, even if it forms a less stable carbocation.
So even if the longer chain could form a more stable carbocation, the fragmentation mechanism may have favored the methyl group carrying the charge.